Jump to content
Coral Vue Hydros

Official Mandarin and Dragonet Show off thread


metrokat

Mandarin Training  

164 members have voted

  1. 1. Does your Mandarin Fish eat Frozen?

    • Yes & I trained my mandarin
    • Yes & I had nothing to do with it
    • No
  2. 2. Answer this if you have a 2nd Mandarin Fish

    • Yes & I trained my mandarin
    • Yes & I had nothing to do with it
    • No
    • I don't have a second Mandy


Recommended Posts

JoeDigiorgio

Well fed males of different species probably won't fight.

 

Aggression in your situation is secondary to food not space. What inevitably happens is one out competes the other leaving one or both feeling like there is something worth fighting for. Micro fauna populations are fickle and come and go in waves over time whether it seems so or not so you can't rely on them that way.

 

You're not going to find a lot of support here for not getting them onto prepared food, and even less for trying it with more than one. Like I said, you're going to do whatever you want so no point in looking for approval.

 

Healthy mandarins will try new things. There's really no reason to not find things to at least reliably supplement both with in addition to letting them enjoy amphipods and what not while you're away from the tank.

Link to comment

I appreciate the write up. Despite my post count I'm not entirely new, just spent the bulk of my time on RC and my local reef forums. I've had my male target Mandy for 2 years now and he's doing fantastic. Just never has take. To any form of prepared foods despite my frequent efforts. It hasn't been an issue at all, as i have set my sump up specifically with pod growing in mind. I realize no setup is fool proof but it's done well. I even removed my protein skimmer partially to preserve pod populations.

 

I'm also a big proponent of the "it's your tank do what you want, you're only seeking advice for someone to validate a bad idea" adage so I do take that to heart. I haven't had my heart set on a second mandarin, just have a friend getting out who has a beautiful blue mandarin in his tank and I wanted to get more opinions on adopting it.

 

Based on responses which make perfect sense I'm going to pass. I am attatched to mine at this point and don't want to do anything to put him in jeopardy

Link to comment
JoeDigiorgio

Is the blue eating anything reliably? How big is your tank? I don't mean to be/sound rude but there's a lot of people looking for support of bad ideas and they get testy when they don't get it.

 

I'm not saying it isn't possible. Well fed mandarins don't like to fight but blue are especially mean once they decide fighting is an option. If one were going to lose it would be the one you're more attached to.

It could be as simple as finding just one frozen food they love, and allowing the pods in the tank do the rest. That guarantees they get at least a nice full belly once or twice a day and don't resort to fighting.

Link to comment

You could also use my situation as a cautionary tale. I have two mandys. Male will eat prepared, I have not found anything for the female even though she was sold to me as eating g prepared. Now I have Ich in my display and have to move everyone. It will be very interesting to see if I have two mandys in the end. If the female was eating prepared, I could confidently tell you yes, they will both be alive, but since she isn't, I can't say that for sure. Prepared foods is a good safeguard for these circumstances.

Link to comment

Not rude to give sound advice. I had reservations so I asked. Tank is probably on the small side for 2. Even a mated pair. 90 display 40 sump, no skimming, all 3 chambers filled completely with rock.

 

I've tried quite a bit with frozen to no avail. Formula 1&2 frozen, various hikari packs, PE mysis, cyclopeeze, reef chili, all manner of nls pellets, San Francisco Bay frozen packs. Reef frenzy, reef roids, rods food. Ignores it all even when target fed. He's not shy or afraid of my hand either

Link to comment
JoeDigiorgio

Not rude to give sound advice. I had reservations so I asked. Tank is probably on the small side for 2. Even a mated pair. 90 display 40 sump, no skimming, all 3 chambers filled completely with rock.

I've tried quite a bit with frozen to no avail. Formula 1&2 frozen, various hikari packs, PE mysis, cyclopeeze, reef chili, all manner of nls pellets, San Francisco Bay frozen packs. Reef frenzy, reef roids, rods food. Ignores it all even when target fed. He's not shy or afraid of my hand either

Try live black worms. Most stores can get them if you ask nicely.

 

In my honest opinion a 90 is actually too big and here is why I feel that way. In a tank with that much space, it's next to impossible to target feed, which I'm sure you've experienced. They move away from the pipette, other fish come in, the mandarin never learns the pipette is a good thing not a bad one. I'd be willing to bet that in a more confined area, you'd get your mandarin eating prepped foods quickly.

  • Like 2
Link to comment

bpb, If you look back a couple pages, you can see the mandarin box I built. It worked for my male, but my female has yet to go in it.

Link to comment
lessergeneration

What do you guys think about lobster roe? We have a group buy going on and I bought a pack of lobster eggs. Hoping this is something my mandarin will like.

At one time i fed mine crayfish eggs haha. As long as they aren't too large i don't see an issue

Link to comment
JoeDigiorgio

What do you guys think about lobster roe? We have a group buy going on and I bought a pack of lobster eggs. Hoping this is something my mandarin will like.

 

Is the group buy happening in America? I want in.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
LebaneseDlight

Joined the club this week. Pair of Red Scooters from my LFS (lucky me) Unique Corals. Eating frozen mysis from day one. The smaller one looks hungry though. I've supplemented with a ton of pods. Fingas Crossed!

 

http://vid33.photobucket.com/albums/d72/gregsarkissian/IMG_3394.mp4

 

<embed width="600" height="361" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowFullscreen="true" allowNetworking="all" wmode="transparent" src="http://static.photobucket.com/player.swf"flashvars="file=http%3A%2F%2Fvid33.photobucket.com%2Falbums%2Fd72%2Fgregsarkissian%2FIMG_3394.mp4&title=">

  • Like 1
Link to comment
gulfsurfer101

I have rotifers. I can send you lots and lots of them.

Here's a pic I got today as a matter of fact as I had all pumps killed and was feeding my coral a bunch of live rotifers.

 

20150503_152044_zpsnwqj2g7f.jpg

  • Like 3
Link to comment
jamescstein
gulfsurfer101

My red mandarin is so elusive, whenever he is visible and I get my shot into focus, he's gone! It's so annoying lol.

Link to comment
JoeDigiorgio

Odd that you had so much die off before the end of prolarvae. You're probably right that it had to do with the parents' condition. What kind of copepod are you culturing right now? I'd bet Parvocalanus would get the job done for you.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
jamescstein

Odd that you had so much die off before the end of prolarvae. You're probably right that it had to do with the parents' condition. What kind of copepod are you culturing right now? I'd bet Parvocalanus would get the job done for you.

 

Yes parvo, tisbe, pseudo, a-tonza and tiggers. The parvo is specifically for the mandrain larvae since they need small pelagic pods for food.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
JoeDigiorgio

Well...I agree parvo would be best but I'm sure you're aware that spotted mandarins have been settled on A tonsa which many consider easier to culture. I just got my Iso cultures back up and running for parvo myself to supplement my orchid dottybacks and hopefully get some picturatus to settlement this summer.

 

 

Oh...and I picked up a very nice male ruby red today. Stumbled upon him while I was store hopping looking for healthy female picturatus. Didn't find my spotted mandarin but now I have one half of two different dragonet projects for the summer lol wish two halves made a whole for me.

Link to comment

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recommended Discussions

×
×
  • Create New...