Jump to content
Top Shelf Aquatics

Smallest external protien skimmer you have seen?


CodeToad

Recommended Posts

Undertheradar: I cought back up on this thread and I really like your design alot better than the one I was kicking around. I went ahead and threw one togather today, I'll let ya'll know how it works out for me :D

Link to comment
  • Replies 895
  • Created
  • Last Reply

The chamber in a nanocube is about 10inches tall(if you run your water level to about the middle of the top intake), 2.75 inches from front to back and 3.25 inches left to right.

 

That leaves about 2inches above the waterline. Not a lot of room to collect foam.

 

However, I've been playing with the idea of using silicon to seal off the bottom 1-2 slits between chamber 2 and 3. Hopefully this will lower water level in chamber 3 to allow for the injector to be placed lower with enough room for a good size collector.

 

I'm going to pick up some Plexi from home depot tmrw, any suggestions on a thickness?

 

Hell if my nano doesn't really need to skim to work, it's fun to learn new things and make sh*t yourself.

Link to comment

morphx,

I think on page 2 or so UTR says that he uses 1/8" plexi. Also, there's significant room above the waterline--I've tried putting a pretty big PH in that back that sat way above the top of the chambers. (I just haven't measure exactly how much room is there. Seems that if you cut off the bottom you'd want the skimmer to perhaps even touch the lid at the top to keep it from floating up when it's turned on. . . .

Link to comment
  • 2 weeks later...

I have a quick question. I built this skimmer yesterday and I am having a problem. When it is running te bubbles will fill the skimmmate chamber with water. What am I doing wrong here? Is the ph too big I have a mini jet 606 running on the lowest setting. Could the injector holes be too big? I use 3 1/8 inch holes. Any other thouhgts?

Link to comment
Undertheradar

It sounds like the flow into the skimmer is too much. Tell me, what is that pump rated for? I would suggest a pump in the 90gph range. Your hole size seems right however. The other thing to check would be how tall your skimmate overflow wall would be...perhaps it is too low? A pic would give me the ability to make a 100% accurate solution.

Link to comment

UTR

The pump is rated from 79-157gph. I have tried to run it at all the speeds. I am at work so I will try to post a pic tonight when i get home. It still overflows on the lowest setting.

Link to comment

UTR,

 

make sure you file a patent disclosure first with the US government before contacting AquaC team.

Otherwise, they could take your idea / suggestions and productize it into their product and file a patent on what you disclosed to them.... In most of the cases, it's not who came up with the ideas owns the patent, but the first person filed it owns it.

 

Art

Link to comment

So, UTR, after getting the patent issue solved, are you going to be selling these skimmers? Is anyone selling just the skimmer body (less injector)? I can make an injector in like 5 minutes but the rest might take a tad bit longer. Also, can someone post the final, best design or tell me what page it is on?

 

Sam

Link to comment
Undertheradar

Mai, your riser area is way too narrow. It should be about 1" at the bottom and 3/4" at the top. It appears that you are making yours out of 1/4" plexi as well...this is prolly the reason you are ending up with such a narrow riser area. The design is using 1/8" only. So you would have to add about 1/2" to the width (from 3" to 3.5") if you wanted to use 1/4". Not needed however.

 

Hold you horses everyone. I am moving this week, so Im a little busy, but not to worry, the lawyer is already working on it for me and the ball is in his court...just have to wait and see what he somes back with. Otherwise I have had three liscencing/mfg offers pending the patents approval. We will just have to wait and see...

Link to comment
DRZL-sauras

I am in the process of makin this skimmer but i made a few changes due to the fact i couldnt find 1/2 pvc in HD...so i bought 3/4 and since it was a little bit larger and my pump an aquqaglobe a little stronger (100 gph) than your 80...i thought of it as compensating for some of the "bigger"parts of my skimmer so i made the skimmer 3 in wide instead of 2.5...everything else is its normal size....im just wonderin will this make my skimmer not work?...also any suggestions on the amount of holes and size in the 3/4 injector.....sorry to ***** about "my skimmer":blush: i just need to hear it from the lions mouth

Link to comment

Undertheradar,

 

I've just built a skimmer based on your plans -- btw, congratulations on such a great design, and thanks for sharing!

 

Here's a picture, the acrylic cement is still curing so I haven't tested the skimmer yet:

 

reef-diy-skimmer-20040721.jpg

 

I have one remaining question at this point: how do you attach the intake (the 1/2" CPVC pipe) to the output of the powerhead? I'm planning on using a MaxiJet 400 (106gph).

 

Thanks,

Nuno

Link to comment

phatmike: I know the cementing job looks terrible... I couldn't find Weldon locally and went with an alternative cement/solvent (it's the same ingredient, but much thicker). I'll post the brand name later, can't remember it now. Anyway, this will be mostly hidden behind the tank, so no big deal... just hoping it will not leak :-)

 

Nuno

Link to comment

I am going to have to rip off my nano cube hood, rebuild another one, and build the radar skimmer, Im serious. First I build the hood, than the skimmer, then the fuge, then get the 70w mh setup.

Link to comment
Undertheradar

Sorry I havent checked up on all the going's on recently...I just moved this weekend...all weekend and then some. The reefs were the last thing to move, as the lease on the old place is two weeks after the new one started...this gave me a nice step-by-step transfer time. Now I have to get the big tank back from my parents (stowed it there to avoid having to move the thing during moving). Well, enough on that, Ill have a complete other thread on that and the new tank (it looks sweeeeeeet now).

 

The reason I mention this is if any of you still have something you are wondering or asked while I was too busy, go ahead and give me a shot now.

Link to comment

do you think it would be possible to builld 1 that is 8" long, 24" tall and 3" wide. And use the return from my sump which is about 500 Gph to power it.

Link to comment

I Have a 55 gallon tank 10 g sump/refugium. I consider this a small tank, I wouldnt go so far as to say it is nano though. your skimmer idea is genious and I was wondering if you think the 4mentioned skimmer would work better than a red sea prism? I don't think the prism is large enough 4 my tank.

Link to comment

Undertheradar: as I mentioned in an earlier post (see above), I just finished building a skimmer based on your plans.

 

Despite the messy cementing job, the skimmer is watertight and doesn't leak.

 

After trying a few injectors (with different number of holes and hole sizes) I think I found one that works with my pump (a Maxijet 400, 110gph).

 

I'm testing it now in a bucket with tank water (ie, dirty salt water) and while I do get lots of bubbles in the skimmer (almost all the way to the bottom baffle), no bubbles are collecting in the collection chamber... actually, they don't even climb up the riser area... any ideas what might be wrong? Or do I just need to run longer to break it in?

 

Here's a picture:

 

reef-diy-skimmer-test-20040723.jpg

 

You can see that there are no bubbles accumulating on surface of the riser area (right side)... they do get there but burst almost immediately.

 

Thanks,

Nuno

Link to comment

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recommended Discussions


×
×
  • Create New...