Jump to content


Photo

THE ULTIMATE ID THREAD! Before you post WHATS THIS? LOOK HERE!


  • Please log in to reply
248 replies to this topic

#1
Helfrichs Chick

Helfrichs Chick

    Nano Reefer

  • Members
  • 1,495 posts
  • Joined 11 Mar 2006
  • Phx AZ

Ok I see sooooo many “WHAT IS THIS” posts. I decided to make a thread where people can come look BEFORE they post. SO I hope this helps someone. Also help pass this along to anyone who is looking for an ID. Its taken me a while but let me know if I forgot anything I will add it. Its going to be very basic with a brief description and with pictures that will be under each description. The goals of this is not to provide information to get rid of the hitchhikers, or any detailed info but to simply ID them and then leave it up to you to search and find more information on removal of critters and algae.

I will start with the harmless critters:

Amphipods, Copepods, Good Isopods and Just Bugs: Pics in that order. HARMLESS
Now there are some 5,000 species so I will list the most common ones. These are all harmless, you will see them on the glass rocks and your hand if you leave it in there long enough, These are the most common species. Pictures in this order, Amphipods, Copepods, Isopods.
Posted ImagePosted ImagePosted Image

Mysis Shrimp: HARMLESS
You will probably only get a short glimpse they are VERY fast lol. You will almost always see them in your fuge, sump or back in the LR at night. At night with a flashlight their eyes will glow. They also make great tasty treats for your fish so as they reproduce toss them in the display!
Posted Image

Bristle Worms: HARMLESS
Jury is out on these, but IMO if they stay small they are harmless and actually keep your sand nice and clean. There are also large other species that can be very damaging to a reef tank, they will be listed later.
Posted Image

Spirorbis: HARMLESS
Tiny while calcareous worms, that mostly will develop in the dark areas. Filter feeders and a sign your tank is doing well, very common.
Posted Image

Feather Duster Worms: HARMLESS
Again like pods there are too many to list here however they are harmless filter feeders, and some can be BEAUTIFUL! I have some red spotted ones and some pretty frilly white ones.
Posted ImagePosted Image

Stomatellas: HARMLESS
Probably the most common “WHATS THAT!?!?!” Looks like a snail with ½ a shell. You’ve got to love these guys they are SOO cute! If I could buy them at my LFS I would. GREAT algae grazers, and have been known to even eat cyano.
Posted ImagePosted Image

Collonista Snails: HARMLESS
Often mistaken as sundial snails, these are harmless grazers. They multiply very quickly and while they are out in the daytime, you will usually see tons on the glass at night.
Posted Image Posted Image
thanks tuidizzle for that second pic.

Edited by Helfrichs Chick, 28 January 2008 - 12:16 PM.


#2
Helfrichs Chick

Helfrichs Chick

    Nano Reefer

  • Members
  • 1,495 posts
  • Joined 11 Mar 2006
  • Phx AZ
Brachiopods: HARMLESS
Hard to find an ID on these, but they look like little clams (rounded edges sometimes rippled) imbedded in your rocks. They are bivalves and are on a hinge and look similar to clams, and mussels. They are filter feeders.
Posted Image

Asteriniid stars: HARMLESS
Occasionally, some populations of these asterinids have been reported by aquarists to eat either soft corals or stony corals. These coral-eating forms, perhaps different species, seem to be really uncommon, constituting less than five percent of the various populations. So I will list them here but observe with caution.
Posted Image

Foraminiferans: HARMLESS
These are really interesting things. Often miss labeled as corals, or sponges these animals actually are one of the oldest forms of life on Earth. Pretty amazing and very common in our tanks. I see those white looking disk ones all the time, and the red ones are really beautiful.
Posted ImagePosted Image

Spaghetti worm and Hair Worms: HARMLESS
While these are considered harmless I have noticed they can really bug corals especially zoas so much to the point the corals will not open. They scavenge the sand and rocks as far as they can reach. Pretty strong too I have seen mine reel in large pellet food. Kinda cool lol.
Hair Worms looks very similar only they have just 2 feeding arms.
Posted Image Posted Image

Limpets: HARMLESS
Harmless little guys, and pretty cute too. Algae grazers that usually come in on the rock. There are lots of species but most have a pointed shell, and pretty easy id.
Posted ImagePosted Image

Sponges: HARMLESS
Ok so here is another "WHATS THIS" that I see all the time. There are so many color variations and different textures but here are a few common ones. Yellow, white, brown, tan, cream, red, orange and blue and pink are all ones I have seen. They are easy to ID by the fact that they always have a tube like structure, it may be very short for an exhale, they often have a web looking texture. They are filter feeders and a great thing to have.
Posted ImagePosted ImagePosted ImagePosted ImagePosted Image

Edited by Helfrich’s Chick, 06 October 2007 - 12:24 PM.


#3
Helfrichs Chick

Helfrichs Chick

    Nano Reefer

  • Members
  • 1,495 posts
  • Joined 11 Mar 2006
  • Phx AZ
Tunicates: HARMLESS
These can be tricky to ID. Some look very much like sponges. Most are round tall cylinders with 2 vents inhale and exhale. Often clear but also white and on some occasions blue, red and other beautiful colors.
Posted ImagePosted Image

Peanut Worms: HARMLESS
Ugly little guys, great for cleaning up the tank thou, eating detritus and various in sand materials. Mainly nocturnal.
Posted ImagePosted Image
Photos courtesy of C est ma. These are the feeding tubes, likely to see them during the day.
Posted ImagePosted Image

Chitons: HARMLESS
Hard as rocks, and look like rocks too. Almost looks like flat potato bug.
Posted Image

Vermetid: HARMLESS
Typically harmful if nothing is around. I have noticed that these things (I have some big ones) when they create their slime trail it really bugs all your corals. They will keep zoas closed up completely and really irritate any others to the point that it will kill the coral. I have personally even lost colonies because of these. So just watch with caution.
Posted ImagePosted Image

And now the harmful critters:

Nudibranchs and their Eggs: HARMFUL
There are MANY species, however a few common are the Zoanthid Nudi, the Montipora Nudi, and Soft coral Nudi Pictured in that order below. Lately it seems like almost every colony of Zoas is infected. These nudis are usually very hard to spot and blend in with their food (your corals) Some can be removed by dipping others you just got to find and pry them off. Egg masses are hard to spot, and vary depending on species.
Posted ImagePosted ImagePosted Image
Posted Image

Aptasia & Mejano: HARMFUL
These are a big time PITA. They move around pop up out of nowhere. They can sting corals and if big enough eat small gobies and such. There are different kinds and colors, and all hard to kill. Aptasia are stronger than Mejanos but still can harm corals. Some people like Mejanos lol and actually buy them… they are kinda pretty lol.
Posted ImagePosted Image

Creoland Isopod: HARMFUL
Like ticks on dogs they will slowly feed on your fish. Removal can be tricky but can be done. You defiantly want these out of your tank.
Posted ImagePosted Image

Edited by Helfrich’s Chick, 06 October 2007 - 06:41 PM.


#4
Helfrichs Chick

Helfrichs Chick

    Nano Reefer

  • Members
  • 1,495 posts
  • Joined 11 Mar 2006
  • Phx AZ
Zoanthid Spiders: HARMFUL
Nasty buggers. If you have a sick colony, that’s not opening look for these guys. Manually remove any you can find and QT. They typically are very small.
Posted Image

Red Bugs: HARMFUL
Found on SPS, and VERY tiny. Hard to see but will have a orange-ish color and will look like little dots. I put these in harmful, but I think most hobbyists have these in their tank. Seems impossible even with proper dipping methods to kill them all.
Posted Image

Sundial Snail: HARMFUL
Harmful to zoanthids. Usually easy to spot and remove, however babies can be pretty tiny.
Posted ImagePosted Image

Flatworms: (Not all are bad, clear ones are harmless) HARMFUL
Usually a rusty red color (clear flatworms are harmless and algae grazers) and can over take a tank easily. Removal is tricky, as they can release toxins when killed, using a air line tube, suctioning these out is the best method.
Posted Image

Pistol and Mantis Shrimp: HARMFUL
Pretty harmless to corals and such, but can spit your finger right open. Can also harm and kill fish, as well as CUC members. These both come in a huge variety of colors and sizes, but you will always know they are there by the loud snapping noise.
Posted ImagePosted Image

Rock Crabs: HARMFUL
These are hard to spot and usually come out at night, They will eat anything they can catch including small fish and CUC members if they get hungry enough. They can also grow pretty large at times. A tell tale sign you have one or more is that you will see the shed, especially the large claw shed.
Posted Image

Fire Worms: HARMFUL
Nasty critters. These will feed on your corals and inflict a painful sting if touched. Sometimes fire worms can be hard to distinguish from common bristle worms.
Posted ImagePosted Image
Posted Image

Edited by Helfrich’s Chick, 11 October 2007 - 04:58 PM.


#5
Helfrichs Chick

Helfrichs Chick

    Nano Reefer

  • Members
  • 1,495 posts
  • Joined 11 Mar 2006
  • Phx AZ
Algae and Plants

Cyano Bacteria:
Slimy looking algae usually dark red. This is a bad algae and can take over a tank.
Posted Image

Diatoms:
Looks like a brown dust, sometimes a orange-rust color dusting over sand and rocks. This is COMMON while your tank is new. Not harmful and will usually go away on its own.
Posted Image

Dinoflagelates:
I have seen this somewhat often lately on NR. it’s a more rare “algae” and like cyano its not really an algae at all. It sometimes looks like diatoms, with a rust color, but usually is more stringy and usually (not always) grows bubbles.
More info here.
http://www.geo.ucalg...lagellates.html
Posted Image

Green Hair Algae:
Probably the most common algae. Can spread over a tank quickly.
Posted Image

Bubble Algae:
Another pest algae. Usually wait until it gets bigger then twist off. Some people like the way they look lol.
Posted Image

Macro Species:
There are many different species: Please see this site for more info:
Posted ImagePosted Image

Here is a site with many different species of macro.
http://images.google...htt...l=en&sa=N

Coralline Species:
Comes in many colors and varieties. Most common is a nice purple color. Also in greens, whites, pinks and my favorite teal. This is a good algae.
Posted ImagePosted ImagePosted Image


HERMITS!!! This site is not in english but it gives the species names of TONS OF HERMITS! Its a great site! Thank you jaidexl for the link!!!!
http://www.recif.be/article/hermit.htm

PLEASE NOTE:
More information of almost all these critters can be found here:
http://www.reefkeepi...vertebrates.php or www.wetwebmedia.com or www.melvesreef.com I claim no pictures as my own, all were found on their respective sites.

Edited by Helfrich’s Chick, 11 October 2007 - 04:56 PM.


#6
Helfrichs Chick

Helfrichs Chick

    Nano Reefer

  • Members
  • 1,495 posts
  • Joined 11 Mar 2006
  • Phx AZ
WHEW, ok thats all I have for now. I think I covered most of the comon hitchikers. Sorry I had to do it in multiple posts, and I have an email out to CM about making this easier to use with a sticky. If there is something you would like to add please shoot me a pm and let me know. THANKS and hope you found this useful.

#7
Yurei

Yurei

    Nano Reefer

  • Members
  • 331 posts
  • Joined 24 Aug 2007
That was awesome!! It helped me tons and would've helped me tons if I read it first before asking!!!


This SO needs a sticky.

#8
fraggle rockette

fraggle rockette

    Nano Reefer

  • Members
  • 2,282 posts
  • Joined 04 Mar 2007
  • Los Angeles, CA
good job HC! very useful for noobs and olds alike!

p.s. if anyone in socal has majanos they're trying to get rid of and can get them out, bring them to meee! :D
XANADUUUU!!! (and sometimes don't): My 24G AP

i'm really not gay... i was once engaged to a slab of bacon with a vagina. true story

why do people get so enraged by someone making fun of a FISHTANK?? this is the one thing i can't wrap my head around... IT'S A BOX OF WATER, PEOPLE. I'M NOT BANGING THE GUY'S WIFE OR ANYTHING.

Cell mate: "what you in for?"
You: "Me? Coral price switching---It was an acro and I called it chaeto"
Cell mate: "Hey look, there's a dollar bill on the floor--can you get that?"


#9
Helfrichs Chick

Helfrichs Chick

    Nano Reefer

  • Members
  • 1,495 posts
  • Joined 11 Mar 2006
  • Phx AZ
Good deal! This is meant to be a very quick refrence, so that you can ID the critter and go on searching for more info. If people have additional personal pics of a critter thats listed or not listed please feel free to add it, better yet send it to me and I will see if I can insert it into the first 3 posts with the rest.

C es ma, made a good point, peanut worms while at night they may look like the pic above during the day you may just see a little trunk sticking out of the rock. This is a perfect chance to add your pics, they will be helpfull for anyone. After all, no way I could get pics and descriptions of every weird critter that pops up lol. I have been in the hobby for a long time but until this I didnt know the name of those little white spirals and now I know their called Spiriobs. Thanks again all and glad this is helpful!!

#10
SPerry

SPerry

    Nano Reefer

  • Members
  • 1,159 posts
  • Joined 19 Oct 2006
  • West Tennessee
Really good post. It should be a sticky in the beginner section.

Can I help it that I am a REEFING ICON and everyone wants to talk to me???


Posted Image

#11
lgreen

lgreen

    Nano Reefer

  • Members
  • 16,412 posts
  • Joined 17 Mar 2004
  • Idaho
Dizam! Glad someone finally got around to doing this.

#12
joel sandoman

joel sandoman

    Bay Area

  • Members
  • 1,968 posts
  • Joined 28 Nov 2005
  • San Lorenzo, CA
^^^
and in the id section too

#13
suppressive fire

suppressive fire

    B ( o Y o ) bies

  • Members
  • 1,201 posts
  • Joined 08 Mar 2007
  • Buffalo, NY
some one put alot of time in this lol great work!!!!!!!!!!!!!

#14
Helfrichs Chick

Helfrichs Chick

    Nano Reefer

  • Members
  • 1,495 posts
  • Joined 11 Mar 2006
  • Phx AZ
YEA we got a sticky!!! THANKS ALL glad you like it!!

Edited by Helfrich’s Chick, 11 October 2007 - 05:01 PM.


#15
Todesengel

Todesengel

    Itchy Balls

  • Members
  • 1,339 posts
  • Joined 09 Aug 2007
  • Chandler, AZ
What do I got here?

First one kinda looks like a white spiral, with a feather duster thing coming out of it. There are THOUSANDS of them in my tank, on the glass, and all over the rock. And I am not joking, they are EVERYWHERE! From the pics above they look like Spirorbis, but the feather duster part doesent look quite the same... yet the biggest one is only the size of a pinpoint.

2nd ones, are almost microscopic. Some with a pink and some with transparent bodies, they have 4 arms that look like a thread of spit, some have 5 arms. Look like super tiny star fish.

#16
Cuervo420

Cuervo420

    Mmm, Cookies.

  • Members
  • 381 posts
  • Joined 14 Nov 2003
  • Oil Country, TX
thanks for your hard work...great post helfrich's chick!! :bowdown:

i'm really not gay... i was once engaged to a slab of bacon with a vagina. true story

I KNEW you were teh ghey ! I KNEW IT !!

Vagina.

nothin like a juicy cookie though.

Darwin. Everyone wants to support the theory, but no one wants it to play out.


#17
Dusko

Dusko

    Nano Reefer

  • Members
  • 17 posts
  • Joined 30 Aug 2007
  • Sweden
Thanks BIG time for this Sticky :)

I almost asked "What is this" but after reading this fabulous article I got the answer;

Chitons: HARMLESS, cute little creature IMO.
I can add one thing about them;

Its been about two month now since I started this nano, and I have noticed this "shell" on a living rock.
It didn't move for 2 moth now and I was thinking it must be some kind of fossilized animal...BUT then yesterday it moved!!!
I was scratching my head for a while .... did this critter hibernate for a while...??? I mean this rock comes from Fiji... well something must have trigered this lil fellow to take action :D

I am glad it is harmless, kind a cute looking.
Posted Image
Posted Image

Thanks once again!
Kind regards, Dusko.
Posted Image

#18
Helfrichs Chick

Helfrichs Chick

    Nano Reefer

  • Members
  • 1,495 posts
  • Joined 11 Mar 2006
  • Phx AZ
Awesome! I am so glad this thread is actually helping! Dusko I love chitons. They are really interesting animals. I had one that was over 2 inches long in my first tank, it was a 125. Same as you I knew it was something and not rock, just sat there for months then one day he was on the move. Very cool critters.

Tod, your first ones do sound like Spirobs, they usually do have a feather coming out which is their feding aparatus.
The second ones your talking about sound very much like a form of Hydroid. Hydroids have all diffrent life stages, and thats my guess without a pic. Usually they look like stars and have little balls on the end of their arms, and are VERY tiny. HTH

Thanks for all the positive feedback and IM's guys!!

#19
dvlax40

dvlax40

    Nano Reefer

  • Members
  • 137 posts
  • Joined 19 Sep 2007
  • phoenix
hey helfrics chick thats my photo i posted on rc in the frag haha :0 glad i could help,

#20
Helfrichs Chick

Helfrichs Chick

    Nano Reefer

  • Members
  • 1,495 posts
  • Joined 11 Mar 2006
  • Phx AZ
^ Huh? What pic?

#21
rbrusletto

rbrusletto

    Nano Reefer

  • Members
  • 512 posts
  • Joined 27 Feb 2007
awesome work HC!

#22
dvlax40

dvlax40

    Nano Reefer

  • Members
  • 137 posts
  • Joined 19 Sep 2007
  • phoenix

awesome work HC!

you used my diatom pic

#23
nanu-nanu

nanu-nanu

    NCNRS #001

  • Members
  • 587 posts
  • Joined 09 Jun 2007
  • San Francisco, Daly City
just found one of these buggers in my colony!
Posted Image
got him out looked kinda cute.
came to check out this thread!
BINGO!
die scum die!
20 High 24" x 18" x 12" Rimless black silicone.
2x RapidLED Par30 15w LED
MP10 ecosmart, Reefkeeper Lite

#24
dopamine

dopamine

    run, you fools!

  • Members
  • 1,664 posts
  • Joined 03 Oct 2007
  • Indianapolis, IN
This kinda looks like a nudi. The polyps close when it is around. I tried to syringe it off but it would let go! any help?

Posted Image
Dopamine's BC14 - modded w/ tons of novice pics

I like ducks.

"The facts of life are conservative."

#25
dopamine

dopamine

    run, you fools!

  • Members
  • 1,664 posts
  • Joined 03 Oct 2007
  • Indianapolis, IN
any thoughts? I am leaving tonight and would like to identify and destroy (if applicable).
Dopamine's BC14 - modded w/ tons of novice pics

I like ducks.

"The facts of life are conservative."