Hob filter for 5g

[Clown79]

Do you think a standar 5g could support a seachem tidal 55?

 

concerned with the tank being able to handle the weight of the hob.

[j.falk]

Seems like overkill for such a small tank...not to mention the relatively small rim size of a 5 1/2 gallon aquarium.

[seabass]

The weight is primarily going down (horizontal) on the panel, which shouldn't a problem.  But I'd think that the vertical pressure on the panel might be a little more concerning; although I'd still guess it'll be alright.  If you still have concerns, the Tidal 35 is a little smaller, and might be more suitable for a thin walled 5.5 gallon tank.

 

However, actually, I would probably just go with another brand (smaller filter).

[Clown79]

20 minutes ago, seabass said:

The weight is primarily going down (horizontal) on the panel, which shouldn't a problem.  But I'd think that the vertical pressure on the panel might be a little more concerning; although I'd still guess it'll be alright.  If you still have concerns, the Tidal 35 is a little smaller, and might be more suitable for a thin walled 5.5 gallon tank.

 

However, actually, I would probably just go with another brand (smaller filter).

I have the 55 sitting around, It was pretty expensive, trying to use it rather than spend money on another filter. But i may just have to.

 

 i'm not really comfortable using it on such a small tank, honestly especially since the glass is so thin on the smaller ones

 

 

[j.falk]

What about putting a block underneath the bottom of the filter so that it takes the pressure off of the glass?

[seabass]

17 minutes ago, j.falk said:

What about putting a block underneath the bottom of the filter so that it takes the pressure off of the glass?

Good idea. 👍

[Clown79]

Thats a great idea! 

 

Thank you both for the help.