Jump to content
Cultivated Reef

Slow death


Reef45

Recommended Posts

So I slowly messed up my tank due to no funds and time. I was using fish store water. But stopped and ended lights or/and time and stopped adding fresh saltwater. 

 

Now trying to bring back it. Should I start over or bring it back?  I don’t wanna lose any good I have left. 

Before and after pictures. Take it easy on me I know what time and money I wasted 

F06FDAB1-0FC4-4014-9A37-C1AE0670E2E9.jpeg

B4DF20D8-0F6C-4D6B-9322-606C3DF36113.jpeg

56D3EFD1-BC22-4463-B6C5-F8122F729FC5.jpeg

2B064248-621C-4B7E-A133-7C37A5114D1B.jpeg

  • Sad 1
Link to comment
Just now, Reef45 said:

So I slowly messed up my tank due to no funds and time. I was using fish store water. But stopped and ended lights or/and time and stopped adding fresh saltwater. 

 

Now trying to bring back it. Should I start over or bring it back?  I don’t wanna lose any good I have left. 

Before and after pictures. Take it easy on me I know what time and money I wasted 

F06FDAB1-0FC4-4014-9A37-C1AE0670E2E9.jpeg

B4DF20D8-0F6C-4D6B-9322-606C3DF36113.jpeg

56D3EFD1-BC22-4463-B6C5-F8122F729FC5.jpeg

2B064248-621C-4B7E-A133-7C37A5114D1B.jpeg

This is now sea of death 

315B708F-2D7E-4D2C-B034-A6A9EC909AC6.jpeg

78935370-7281-43E1-93AA-60EDFE794C38.jpeg

3BBCE1B3-E7B7-46CB-BE51-DD277CD1F451.jpeg

4B764DA3-9F9C-4445-8940-C7C89DC42DEE.jpeg

777E596C-FF07-4875-8167-A3DED4F59FE7.jpeg

50C7FBCE-F4A0-4206-A7FB-DBC2C5035F1B.jpeg

8E7CF34F-03AD-4ED0-A2E5-244AFEF481EC.jpeg

5DE283DA-86B9-415E-8444-09AEAA98DBB0.jpeg

F2E41FDD-C20B-4522-8D9C-BBF61B57DDDA.jpeg

3BBB5799-227B-405B-846E-A70FFC32EEC9.jpeg

B647B8A7-6CA1-4D7B-8D99-E550B8198654.jpeg

Link to comment
1 hour ago, Reef45 said:

Should I start over or bring it back?


I would just continue where you’re at now and make a slow recovery.

 

1 hour ago, Reef45 said:

High salt levels  poisoned everything due to evaporate water line in tank and the cold weather. 

 

Make gradual changes in the right direction.  Slowly get your salinity back to where it should be.  Get your water temperatures stable at an appropriate number.  Make sure you have good lighting with an appropriate photoperiod.  Test your water parameters and adjust your calcium and alkalinity levels if needed.  It’s never too late until the moment you give up.

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment

Thank you everyone! I know what I did wrong. It all started with the Hob refugium started getting really nasty then after cleaning that things started going down hill. I was using live rock and just letting the tank clean itself. Then I added  a new powerful hob filter. Then the tank was way to clean and not having any gravel or sand base for the tank given that it’s a bare bottom tank. I think I basically I removed all the good stuff in the tank and changed things too quickly. Corals started to slowly die making it worse in a small tank. Added turbo snails which ended up starving at that point. Plus summer heat and a/c didn’t help. The other thing that happened  was the evaporation was messing with the water levels very quickly. Needing top offs everyday by hand caused spikes in temperature and salt levels. 

 

I am now bringing salt levels back to normal then I will slowly add light and fresh saltwater changes to bring parameters back to normal. I haven’t tested yet. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment

Looks like not everything is dead.  Hard to imagine it's worth totally starting from scratch....but then we still don't have a lot of data to go on.

 

Can you test your specific gravity and post what your reading is now?   And what is the highest level you saw it at?

 

It might be helpful if we knew what the rest of your levels are currently like as well:

 

Ca, Alk, Mg, NO3 and PO4

Link to comment

 specific gravity is now at 1.024

took 3gal of fresh water to get there. 

It was reading so high it didn’t read on hydrometer. 

 

Yes there is life. Rocks are fine. Baby star fish are alive. One coral lived. It’s duncan coral. 

 

I do apologize  for not having a test at this time. 

 

Slowly bringing temp up. 

Link to comment
1 hour ago, Reef45 said:

 specific gravity is now at 1.024

took 3gal of fresh water to get there. 

It was reading so high it didn’t read on hydrometer. 

 

Yes there is life. Rocks are fine. Baby star fish are alive. One coral lived. It’s duncan coral. 

 

I do apologize  for not having a test at this time. 

 

Slowly bringing temp up. 

It sounds mostly like salinity issues, temp issues, and possibly nutrient issues were at play.

 

I would just start lighting the tank, maybe on a shortened photo period to start.

 

Do some tests, alk, ca, nitrates, and phos(not with api phos kit)

 

Weekly waterchanges are best but if you generally have low to no nutrients, I think every 2 weeks would be better until you need to do them weekly. 

 

Your tank just needs to get back into balance.

 

Unfortunately without an ato, you need to top up daily, sometimes twice a day, especially with an open top.

 

I top up every morning and before bed because I manually top up.

Link to comment
second_decimal

Get an ATO.. it’s really one of the most essential pieces of a reef tank. Apart from eliminating the need to constantly tend the salinity and water level, it stabilizes the entire system. 

Link to comment

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recommended Discussions

×
×
  • Create New...