Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Gunbeaux

Pistol Shrimp killing cleanup crew

Recommended Posts

Gunbeaux   

Has anyone had a pistol shrimp kill a snail or hermit crab, mine are disappering and the only thing in that tank is a pistol shrimp there is some large gravel like Live sand in the tank and what looks like crushed shells

Edited by Gunbeaux

Share this post


Link to post
Yves17   

And are you 100% sure theres ONLY a pistol shrimp in your tank?

 

And yes they can kill little hermit crabs and snails

Edited by Yves17

Share this post


Link to post

100% yes. I was only able to keep large nassarius and turbo snails. Any other invert became shrimp/goby food.

Share this post


Link to post

My pistol and YWG both munch on the tiny neriths snails. But, only them outside of eating the food I provide. But, as for anything like my larger snails and hermits no. Size difference.

 

You can also hear the when the shells are being snapped, aside from the routine pistol shrimp gun shoot off. Just something to listen out for.

Edited by surgicalsense

Share this post


Link to post
Kush   

yes, my pistol shrimp just loves to eat the legs off just about any invert, trying to catch the bugger is the problem

Share this post


Link to post
Gunbeaux   

Thanks for the help I can hear him hunting at night I made the mistake of putting the tank in my bedroom and sometime in the middle of the night when I am sound asleep it wakes me up.... at least I know he is eating.

Share this post


Link to post
Thanks for the help I can hear him hunting at night I made the mistake of putting the tank in my bedroom and sometime in the middle of the night when I am sound asleep it wakes me up.... at least I know he is eating.

 

Do you guys keep cleaner shrimps? Any issues there?

Share this post


Link to post
LRStar   

My pistol is a jerk. I will never get another. Kills all my snails, torments my crabs, and has murdered many other shrimp. Not to mention always moving corals, snipping off acans/zoas for decoration, and hoarding food in a stash that screws up my tank.

 

Boooo!

Share this post


Link to post
Do you guys keep cleaner shrimps? Any issues there?

 

I have one fire cleaner. No issues. However, when it molts I leave the molt in the tank. Because Spot my pistol shrimp snatches the molt up and drags it into the den.

Share this post


Link to post
Gunbeaux   

I am glad others are having problems with theres I have set up a 2.6 gal rimless tank for the 3 and under contest an am thinking of puting him in there with a bare bottom so he can't move the sand around every other day. Does anyone think the 2.6 is too small for the shrimp.. might put a goby in there also.

Share this post


Link to post

Don't think he would be happy with that.

Moving sand around is what they do.

Share this post


Link to post
Gunbeaux   

Might just put sand in the tank anyway I work for an engineering company and there are dozers around everywhere.. why not one on my desk.

Share this post


Link to post
gbose   

I've never been able to keep shrimp after getting my Pistol. I've bought like 5 peppermints in the last 6 months; they seem to settle in happily and come out looking for food. An one day, they just disappear...

 

Any yes, my Pistol is the prime suspect, because I've only got small peaceful fish in there. He;s the closest thinkg to a carnivore..

 

GBose

Share this post


Link to post
NathanF   

In the past I've had trouble getting food to my pistol shrimp. My clown and even his goby buddy would gulp food down as fast as it went into the water. I mean, they would take every last pellet to the point where both would hold food in their mouths because they were too full to eat what they had. All the while the pistol would search like mad looking for a morsel. That's when the cleanup crew faced danger. To fix that I picked up a syringe and put a length of airline hose onto the end. I suck up some pellets in water and give a squirt right by the pistol shrimp. Now he's happy and quite non-murderous.

Share this post


Link to post

Biggest problem ive had with pistols and cleaner shrimps, is the cleaners fighting for the pistol's food, and being dragged into the burrow along with the food they are holding on to.

Share this post


Link to post
mbonus   
In the past I've had trouble getting food to my pistol shrimp. ...

 

I have routinely seen the tiger pistol eating "waste" right out of the backside of the goby. So I doubt he'll starve if you don't target feed.

 

Anything that goes by the burrow is fair game as far as he's concerned, that is except the serpent star that is five times his size. :)

Share this post


Link to post
NathanF   
I have routinely seen the tiger pistol eating "waste" right out of the backside of the goby. So I doubt he'll starve if you don't target feed.

 

It's not about preventing him from starving to death. It's about reducing cleanup crew losses.

Share this post


Link to post
mbonus   
It's not about preventing him from starving to death. It's about reducing cleanup crew losses.

 

 

I hear you, whatever works go with it. Anything that goes by the burrow in my tank, becomes a door. :o

Share this post


Link to post
NathanF   
I hear you, whatever works go with it. Anything that goes by the burrow in my tank, becomes a door. :o

 

I have a couple of red leg hermits that never learn. They get dragged into the burrow and eventually climb their way out. My scarlet legged hermits on the other hand seem to have figured out that if they traverse the tank on top of the rocks then they're safe. The change in their behavior has been quite interesting.

Share this post


Link to post
mike c   
I am glad others are having problems with theres I have set up a 2.6 gal rimless tank for the 3 and under contest an am thinking of puting him in there with a bare bottom so he can't move the sand around every other day. Does anyone think the 2.6 is too small for the shrimp.. might put a goby in there also.

 

Definitly do NOT go bare bottom, and definitly give him a goby partner. A small one, like a Hi-Fin Red Band. A pistol shrimps whole life revolves around moving sand and constantly bulldozing. Keeping the goby fed, will in turn keep your pistol fed, as gobies will sometimes feed their shrimp partners. The goby will also protect the den entrance, and push away hermits and snails. This may lessen casualties. When I feed my goby, I shoot a couple mysis shrimp into the den, for good mesure. I havnt lost a snail or hermit since introducing the pistol shrimp. And I have little micro hermits.

Share this post


Link to post
Gunbeaux   

Thanks for all of the reply's I think I am going to put LS in the tank and get him a goby. the take is one I have entered in the 3 and under contest hopefully it is not too small right now he is in a 20L and just stays around one area.

Share this post


Link to post
spoon   

My pistol has ripped legs off my emerald crab and just last weekend took on the peppermint shrimp as a snack. Arrggh

 

Unfortunately, I'd have to take everything out of the tank to catch him.

Share this post


Link to post

Or you could add a juvenile snowflake moray to deal with it... of course, then the problem would be getting it out instead! :lol:

Share this post


Link to post
mbonus   
My pistol has ripped legs off my emerald crab and just last weekend took on the peppermint shrimp as a snack. Arrggh

 

Unfortunately, I'd have to take everything out of the tank to catch him.

 

I assume reverse is what happened just this week in my pico, HH pistol is nowhere to be found . Emerald is the only thing in the tank that could have taken it down. Bummer, cause I liked that little dude. Came in on some zoas and was about 1/4" long. Last I saw it was about 2-1/2". Could have been a bad molt...

Edited by mbonus

Share this post


Link to post

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  
  • Recommended Discussions

  • Sign Up or Sign In to hide this.

×