Is this a good external canister filter for a 5gal?

[z6joker9]

Zoo Med 501 external canister filter. I work at PetsMart and noticed this sucker. It's made for turtle tanks, but looking over it, it might be perfect for a nano if you want a canister filter. It would give you more room on the back and give you a bit of choice on the filter meduims.

 

It runs around $40. I could not find info online, but here is some basic stuff from the box:

 

Volts/Cycles : 110/60

Watts : 4

Max G.P.H : 79

Size of Filter : 6.5" tall, 3.5" deep, and 5.9" long.

 

2 chambers : 1 for filter sponge and 1 for carbon/ceramic media (which comes with the kit)

Says on the box : "Easy priming external filter for turtle tanks, vivariums, box turtle pools, or aquariums up to 30 gallons."

Comes with a spray bar.

Says : "Includes special water pump motor that can run dry for up to 30 days without damaging the unit!"

 

anyone have any experience?

[serjuanca88]

In my opinion it would take up too much space. I would get an external HOB filter. Also $40 at Petsmart is way too much. You can get it online for less than $20.

[z6joker9]

I cannot find it online, and how would it take up space? it's an external canister filter, it sits outside the aquarium. I have a AC mini HOB filter, the purpose of this one would be to save room in the tank.

 

if you have the link of a place to buy, please post it

[darwin604]

I've had great success with my HOB filter on my nano and a canister filter might be a little overkill for a 5g.

 

d.

[palaegic]

Will it work? Probably.

You'll find that the general concensus is that canisters are a PITA.

Whereas a HOB is quick and easy access, particularly for a 5 gallon.

 

Your request falls into the category of "try it and see". You have the choice of trying something that most folks here have not - but would be interested in hearing about the results, be they good or bad.