CaribSea denitrators (between these two)

[Fishtail]

Here's the deal. I am about to place a really large order from Petsolutions, and am currently building a sulfur based denitrifier. Originally, I planned on using the LSM (top link) but they do not have it at Petsolutions. The only place I can find it at is Marine Depot. I just don't want to make two seperate orders is all. I plan on using the aragonite along with the sulfur, so would it matter if they are already mixed (like you see in the second link - NoNitrate).

 

I guess my question is - for anyone who has used a sulfur before - would this really matter? If so, I'll make a seperate order. It just seems kinda redundant.

 

http://tinyurl.com/588ejs

and

http://www.petsolutions.com/NO-Nitrate+I18400527.aspx

 

thanks in advance

[SPS20]

Here's the deal. I am about to place a really large order from Petsolutions, and am currently building a sulfur based denitrifier. Originally, I planned on using the LSM (top link) but they do not have it at Petsolutions. The only place I can find it at is Marine Depot. I just don't want to make two seperate orders is all. I plan on using the aragonite along with the sulfur, so would it matter if they are already mixed (like you see in the second link - NoNitrate).

 

I guess my question is - for anyone who has used a sulfur before - would this really matter? If so, I'll make a seperate order. It just seems kinda redundant.

 

http://tinyurl.com/588ejs

and

http://www.petsolutions.com/NO-Nitrate+I18400527.aspx

 

thanks in advance

 

My understanding is that having it is best to have the water pass through the sulphur medium first, then the aragonite, though I imagine mixing the two would work.

 

Go with the Caribsea, IMO, it is tried-and true.

[Fishtail]

They're both CaribSea! Look at the packaging, they are absolutely identical! And you read about them, they both say the exact same thing. I wonder if they may be taking one off the market, and just going to a mix instead. I think they may be identical minus the aragonite mixed in.

[SPS20]

go with the pure sulphur, IMO.