Design my new 10 - which one guys?

[DannaM]

Bought some really cool dry reef rocks but I'm having a job scaping. They're going in a 10 gallon. Any input on which works or doesn't is a great help

 

 

1

 

2

 

3

 

4

 

5

 

6

 

7

[markalot]

#5 looks the best to me, but I'm not sure why.

[Kevin88]

I like 3.

[rolyat113]

I think I like 5 best as well... One issue I have with my personal scape is I don't have a lot of extra sand room in the front. If I ever do a longer tank I'll have a taller rock structure and then some free sand area broken up by random corals.

[DannaM]

two for 5 and one for 3 so far. Thanks guys...at least if nothing else I'm getting to rule out some

[lex0219]

2, 3, or 6 would get my vote.

[Jackal_Knight]

I Like 2

[vw4life]

I like 2 and 3

[DannaM]

Well, I thank all of you who helped...at least there's a couple I can completely eliminate . Tomorrow I'll sit them in the tank (after I add up which design won more votes) .

 

Thanks

[LynkUK]

3 gets my vote.

[Idontknowz]

2 then 5

[Arkayology]

2 and 6 are the same? I would go with one of those.

[Spiderguardnano]

5 gets my vote

[spazizz]

4

[DannaM]

Thanks everyone! I'll set them in the tank today and you can see which one won

[frankdontsurf]

4, 6, 7.

[DannaM]

4, 6, 7.

Lol...thanks . I'm going to have to do a recount again before I get this set up today lol.

[N.Radd]

I like 5 or 6

[frankdontsurf]

10 gallons since they are wide look great with two islands. So I'm changing to #3 as my favorite, throw in that other rock and make it 3 islands. I actually just redid my scape, I ended up smashing most of my rocks and stuffing them in the filter as rubble.

[DannaM]

10 gallons since they are wide look great with two islands. So I'm changing to #3 as my favorite, throw in that other rock and make it 3 islands. I actually just redid my scape, I ended up smashing most of my rocks and stuffing them in the filter as rubble.

 

Ha! That's a solution The large rock is on the big size for a 10 but it's a really cool rock when you see it in person. Lots of holes and shapes Thanks for your input.

 

I like 5 or 6

thanks.

[gulfsurfer101]

Put me down for 3, k thanks!

[DannaM]

So far 3 is ahead. Unless I get a few more votes (it's pretty close between 2,3 and 5) before I get going then 3 it is You guys have been helpful, thanks.

 

Put me down for 3, k thanks!

[noobofreefs]

I like 3 unless the rock sits too close to the glass. If it does put me down for 2

[dpoltsdsu]

I like 3 the most. Provides a more open scape