Ac810 Posted April 22, 2016 Share Posted April 22, 2016 Just purchased a JBJ 10g saltwater, been cycling since last Friday 4/15. Wondering what you alls thoughts are on fish selection I have about 10 hermit crabs a small shrimp a crab and a brittle starfish. Tank is stocked with live sand and rock. Any recommendations for a first timer? Link to comment
Hard Softy Posted April 22, 2016 Share Posted April 22, 2016 A tiger shark would be cool.... "wink" I'm sure someone will have suggestions soon Link to comment
pappadumplingz Posted April 22, 2016 Share Posted April 22, 2016 M8 a Megaladon shark is the best option for a beginner, can live happily in a 1 gallon vase so I'm sure it can live in a 10 gallon happily. You only need to feed it one cube of mysis shrimp weekly. Link to comment
Anden Posted April 22, 2016 Share Posted April 22, 2016 Get some mushrooms to start out and ad more coral so time goes but 10gallon and fish is not a beginner thing. Link to comment
Cencalfishguy56 Posted April 22, 2016 Share Posted April 22, 2016 Get some mushrooms to start out and ad more coral so time goes but 10gallon and fish is not a beginner thing.thats nonsense lol plenty of 10 gallon nano beginner fish that don't take a lot of effortJust purchased a JBJ 10g saltwater, been cycling since last Friday 4/15. Wondering what you alls thoughts are on fish selection I have about 10 hermit crabs a small shrimp a crab and a brittle starfish. Tank is stocked with live sand and rock. Any recommendations for a first timer?is your cycle done? But I would get a firefish or clownfish for your first fish, both are hardy and accept just about any food Link to comment
tetraodon Posted April 22, 2016 Share Posted April 22, 2016 M8 a Megaladon shark is the best option for a beginner, can live happily in a 1 gallon vase so I'm sure it can live in a 10 gallon happily. You only need to feed it one cube of mysis shrimp weekly. im also guessing it plays well with shy sensitive fish too? Link to comment
Anden Posted April 22, 2016 Share Posted April 22, 2016 thats nonsense lol plenty of 10 gallon nano beginner fish that don't take a lot of effortis your cycle done? But I would get a firefish or clownfish for your first fish, both are hardy and accept just about any food Yes but 10 hermitcraps one crab one shrimp one starfish, and now you want to put fish in it to lol i realy hope the skimmer is a good one. Link to comment
pappadumplingz Posted April 22, 2016 Share Posted April 22, 2016 im also guessing it plays well with shy sensitive fish too? Ye man, a Megaladon would do soooo well in your new 40 gallon. It would have sooo much space! Link to comment
Ac810 Posted April 22, 2016 Author Share Posted April 22, 2016 Thanks. I was planning to add 2 or 3 fish and add a hanging filter to my set up. Im looking to get a maroon clown and go from there I suppose... Link to comment
ReefWeeds Posted April 22, 2016 Share Posted April 22, 2016 Thanks. I was planning to add 2 or 3 fish and add a hanging filter to my set up. Im looking to get a maroon clown and go from there I suppose... I would say a maroon clown is too big for a 10. They tend to be larger. I'd go with a smaller type clown. Also, two fish at MOST with a 10, especially if you're going with a clown. Salt is much different than fresh water in terms of fish stocking. Also, if you just started your tank last Friday, I think you added the hermits, snails and starfish too early personally. The tank needs to cycle and the clean up crew you have will need to eat something. With no algae yet, they most likely will starve unless you are supplementing feedings. And welcome to NR! There's a lot of information available on this forum! If you do some searching, you'll find a wealth of info to help you out. And everyone is very helpful as well. And my one piece of advice: research the heck out of everything before adding to your tank. This goes for fish, corals, inverts, additives, food, etc. Researching I'm sure has saved me from uncertain disaster in this hobby - and not researching has caused me headaches for sure Link to comment
Ac810 Posted April 22, 2016 Author Share Posted April 22, 2016 I started this tank on 4/15 transferred everything over from another tank that had been going for approx a week and a half. And yeah I've been trying to do research and talk with my local fish shop. I've been getting a lot of contradicting info, just trying to toss my ideas out before moving forward Link to comment
ReefWeeds Posted April 22, 2016 Share Posted April 22, 2016 I started this tank on 4/15 transferred everything over from another tank that had been going for approx a week and a half. And yeah I've been trying to do research and talk with my local fish shop. I've been getting a lot of contradicting info, just trying to toss my ideas out before moving forward good to hear on the research! there will always be a ton of contradicting info - there's always never just one way to do something. The key is weeding through, weighing the facts and then making an educated decision. I still think you may have problems with your hermits, snails and star. Even a week and a half isn't enough time in my opinion. Have you been checking to see if the tank cycled? Have you seen an ammonia spike and/or what are your ammonia and nitrate levels? Are you feeding the inhabitants? If you transferred over from a tank that had been up a week and a half, most likely unless you used seeded rock/sand/etc., there wasn't a biofilter that they transferred with. Link to comment
Cencalfishguy56 Posted April 22, 2016 Share Posted April 22, 2016 I would say a maroon clown is too big for a 10. They tend to be larger. I'd go with a smaller type clown. Also, two fish at MOST with a 10, especially if you're going with a clown. Salt is much different than fresh water in terms of fish stocking. Also, if you just started your tank last Friday, I think you added the hermits, snails and starfish too early personally. The tank needs to cycle and the clean up crew you have will need to eat something. With no algae yet, they most likely will starve unless you are supplementing feedings. And welcome to NR! There's a lot of information available on this forum! If you do some searching, you'll find a wealth of info to help you out. And everyone is very helpful as well. And my one piece of advice: research the heck out of everything before adding to your tank. This goes for fish, corals, inverts, additives, food, etc. Researching I'm sure has saved me from uncertain disaster in this hobby - and not researching has caused me headaches for sure stella summed up everything I was thinking, this is the best piece of advice! Link to comment
Astinus Posted April 22, 2016 Share Posted April 22, 2016 And my one piece of advice: research the heck out of everything before adding to your tank. This goes for fish, corals, inverts, additives, food, etc. Researching I'm sure has saved me from uncertain disaster in this hobby - and not researching has caused me headaches for sure I Totally couldn't agree more with what Stella has said. As I am currently in the process of looking to add some Coral to our Tank. And I am researching the heck out of the Coral(s) that look good in Pictures, but, I am cautious as to the Coral's Aggressiveness, I'd rather not get a Coral than to get 1 and later regret losing a Coral due to "War Fare". Also Research the "Fish" u want. Clowns can be aggressive and some will tell you to put a Clown in Last, as it won't be "Dominant". Regarding a Cycle, Get ur self a Good Test kit! I am not an expert on cycles or Cycling, but I did wait. I Used Live Rock (LR) and Live Sand (LS). Got LR from LFS and used 15 or 20 Gallons of their water, directly from their Tanks. My cycle was about 10 days, this is an exception, not the norm. During ur cycle, u will want to do water changes along the way. I Hope ur Clean up crew can survive a cycle. Ammonia can be very harsh to any critter. I Am Glad U found us (NR) and listen to people's advice Most of all.... To NR! and we are most definitely picture Hounds!! We Love Pics!! Enjoy the ride Link to comment
Rural Posted April 22, 2016 Share Posted April 22, 2016 Just purchased a JBJ 10g saltwater, been cycling since last Friday 4/15. Wondering what you alls thoughts are on fish selection I have about 10 hermit crabs a small shrimp a crab and a brittle starfish. Tank is stocked with live sand and rock. Any recommendations for a first timer? here you go. http://www.nano-reef.com/topic/74703-lgreens-ultimate-guide-to-nano-fish/ cant lose with a clown... kids love nemo. Link to comment
Matteo Posted April 23, 2016 Share Posted April 23, 2016 Yes but 10 hermitcraps one crab one shrimp one starfish, and now you want to put fish in it to lol i realy hope the skimmer is a good one. yo water changes and light feeding is all you need. No skimmer on my build! However yes maybe take like 5 hermits back hahah no need for that many. As for fish you could do a clown fish pair or firefish pair. A really great small beginner fish is a clown goby also. Another good one with lots of color is a royal gramma. Keep us posted! also we like pictures here here you go. http://www.nano-reef.com/topic/74703-lgreens-ultimate-guide-to-nano-fish/ cant lose with a clown... kids love nemo. I kick people out of my house if they call my clowns "nemo" Link to comment
Hammerstone Posted April 24, 2016 Share Posted April 24, 2016 yo water changes and light feeding is all you need. No skimmer on my build! However yes maybe take like 5 hermits back hahah no need for that many. As for fish you could do a clown fish pair or firefish pair. A really great small beginner fish is a clown goby also. Another good one with lots of color is a royal gramma. Keep us posted! also we like pictures here I kick people out of my house if they call my clowns "nemo" that always makes me laugh lol. I just call mine Occys. That and Bob and Bill, even though they are a breeding pair. The female I had for a year and a half alone so she was a he and then turned into a female but the name stuck. Now that she has her little man I named him Bill lol.??? Also welcome!!!? Link to comment
NathanC Posted April 24, 2016 Share Posted April 24, 2016 I'm also gonna have to vote with the megalodon just a great peaceful beginner fish. Link to comment
ReeferBrian Posted May 15, 2016 Share Posted May 15, 2016 Hey welcome to reefing! I've been in the hobby for 8 months now and I started with a 10 gallon nano tank,it can be done trust me.my biggest advise would be keep up with a 10% to 20%water change weekly,don't skip!I've found that the 20% water changes work the best for me.I have two fish and I wouldn't do more than that,I have a clownfish,and a yellow watchman goby,and since they occupy two different parts of the tank there seem to be no compatibility issues.over stocking and poor husbandry are two main reasons nano tanks have issues.get a good testing kit not api.as long as you just have soft corals dosing your tank shouldn't be necessary with weekly water changes.research everything and get lots of input from people on here and youtube videos are great for research,but some people give bad advise so get a few opinions on something then research more and you'll have to make a hypothesis based on the info you get.this hobby can be frustrating but very rewarding.most of all ENJOY the hobby it's addicting,I just started a coralife biocube 14 gallon for my wife.she had no interest in my tank at first,but now she has her own.lol good luck!! Link to comment
FlowerMama Posted May 15, 2016 Share Posted May 15, 2016 Best advice- follow what people here say and not the fish shops. Link to comment
ReeferBrian Posted May 19, 2016 Share Posted May 19, 2016 Yeah I agree with flower moma,some lfs will think about profit over sound advise.I have learned a lot on here,and talking to other customers in the lfs while shopping.I have one lfs that has an employee that will say anything to Sell something,needless to say I dont ask her questions anymore,lol but everyone else at the store are pretty good. Link to comment
msparklym13 Posted May 19, 2016 Share Posted May 19, 2016 HI! Welcome and StellaBlue is always my favorite advice friend ;-) Also Rural and Astinus are amazing! Thing is.. I learned about housing a star in the first few months and it didn't do well. Looking back I wish I would have had this forum before purchasing. Any star should not be paired with a CUC for set up. Quite honestly your tank is probably not large enough/stable enough to handle such a delicate creature. Hopefully it will fare well but please know it might not. I hope it goes well for you! Keep us posted.... and laugh at the joke comments- It is always in jest - Know you are a welcome addition!! M8 a Megaladon shark is the best option for a beginner, can live happily in a 1 gallon vase so I'm sure it can live in a 10 gallon happily. You only need to feed it one cube of mysis shrimp weekly. Mine is doing AMAZING in my 29G. I keep thinking maybe he wants more room.. but then he shakes his head at me, jumps up to give a quick hug and assures me all is perfect! Such a doll! Link to comment
Sancho Posted May 19, 2016 Share Posted May 19, 2016 Yellow watchman goby are pretty bulletproof and do well in small tanks as they really dont swim much. You cant go wrong with Ocellaris clowns. With proper maintenance you could definitely keep a few fish in a 10 gallon. Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.