no

yes

Yes, a coralife super skimmer 65.

Yes.

I used to on my 150 g reef system, but I also ran a 10 inch deep sand bed and ozone and calcium reactor. I have a 34 solana now and do not run a skimmer, no mechanical. Just 30 lbs of live rock and 20 % water changes each week.

If your pulling out a full cup of skimmate ever week your just asking for problems. What if you went on week vacation and your protein skimmer broke, that waste would just build up in your system that does not have the equilibrium to handle it. What if the skimmer goes crazy and spews the whole cup of skimmate back into the system (it has happen to me). Live rock does not break. I see a lot of people on here that do not realize that with a nano comes a nano bioload, which means means filling your entire water column with organisms is not only risky but stressful to the coral and fish.

If you want to add more life you need to get a bigger system or have a sump that has 1/2 times the amount of water in display, or just change the water more.

Yes, A Deltec MCE600 on my solana (tank link in signature). IMO it's a must for an SPS keeper.

It's not.

Noob question.
When I upgrade to a 35g, I plan on keeping mostly lps/softies with a few sps and a clam(once tank is well established), would I be overdoing it if I run a skimmer part time and have a fuge?

Protein Skimmer = Yes
Live Rock = definitely

Show me what you got

I know it can be done without one but why would you want to? Skimmers are excellent at exporting wastes and keeping low nutrients is the key to peak colors.

I finally found a thread on skimmers that wasn't 3 years old.

I am looking for advice on to skim or not to skim. I have a BC29 with a HO Refugium, with Chaeto. I am running the light at night for 12 hours. I don't have much in the tank due to neglect for a year and getting back into it. I have had the tank running for 3 years, and went to monthly water changes for a year and lost a lot of my coral. Just didn't have time. Anyway, she is clean and stable, and I have a Aqua C Remora Skimmer sitting in my basement. Not sure if I should use it ( more modding to the tank) or just get an in-tank skimmer or just not use one. Sorry for the long post. I would appreciate any help.

BTW..I have been a lurker for 3 years and this is a great community that has taught me a lot by just reading. Thanks again in advance for any help.

i also have a this skimmer. i have had it on both of my systems first i had it on my 29 show back in cali now its on my 37 never had an issue w/ it. it is the only form of filtration i have. no sock pads or carbon of any kind just LR, LS, and good old NSW. aka the berlin method. IMO a good skimmer and good lighting is all u need.

run mine 24/7

It can be done by increasing the nitrates in a system to about 7~ PPM. This will increase Chaeto's metabolism to make it soak up nutrients like there's no tomorow. But of course, you need strong illumination on the chaeto and alot of it.

All in all, a skimmer is less trouble. I personally love skimmers and their use. However they are not always mandatory, even for SPS tanks.

I do.

I use an Aqua C Remora on my 29. When you see what it pulls out of what I consider a clean tank I couldn't imagine not using one,

Yes...ever smell what a skimmer pulls out even after a day?

Yes. Deltec MCE300.

I run my skimmer at night - programmed with moonlights to come on at same time.
My Actinics come on at 11am and my MH comes on at 2pm and goes off at 8pm- followed by the actinics which kick off at 930pm- the rest of the time, my moonlights and skimmer are on. I generally feed an hour before skimmer kicks in. I dont use any other filter method either- live rock, live sand, protein skimmer, and a weekly 15% water change. (was running the stock rsm 130d protein skimmer)- swapped to the last prototype revision of the sapphire aquatics protein skimmer made for the red sea max line of tanks.

Yep

No skimmer on my 12g...just WCs.

YUP- Aqua C Remora Pro with overflow box and mag drive 5

What skimmer? No skimmer, too noisy.

Skimmerless.

Very nice tank Glenn. What size? What kind of background is that (foam like)?

thanks! the tank is a DIY AIO 20l. the background is foam.

Was the foam background DIY also? If not, where did u get it? It's very good idea to use a foam background. I have a narrow tank, it looks bigger with foam background.

Yep i use a Reef Octopus hang on back

yea, seaclone in-tank skimmer, not the best but it gets the job done

I let my sponges eat the poop water

I like seeing it kinda dirty, more natural, more bugs, more natural all around.

Your natural bio-filter can handle that stuff the skimmer pulls out.

but i got 54w of light on a huge chaeto ball and a fuge half the size of the tank...that is the key

30g main + 14g fuge

4 months...what is a nitrate? I forgot....ammonia, never seen it. Phosphate who?

Nope...

I did for many years, but my newest tank will feature only an algal turf scrubber. Granted, my new tank isn't necessarily a reef, but it will contain some corals and an anemone.

I like the rock work and can't even tell it's foam. Very nice!!!

Where are all of the pics? Here's mine with no skimmer, just small daily water changes and a large weekly.

Whats a skimmer for lol. I use mine for getting air into the completely covered AIO nanowave 9

skimmerless 15g

Nice tank Giannis! Im planning on putting a Tunze 9002 on my 29 BioCube.

Bubble King DeLuxe imo.

Tunze Nano DOC 9002 - New version

Yes...running an Aquac Urchin on a 40b with a 20l sump.

Yes due to heavy feedings. I like to ensure everything is well fed so Skimming is necessary along with automated waterchanges.

Very nice tank and great example that a nice tank can be done skimerless. You use frequent water change to export wastes, some use fuges/scrubbers, chemical media ect.. Bottom line is waste must be exported. I just choose to plug in a bad-a$$ skimmer and let it do the work for me.

what is the protein skimmer?
can you explain to me please,

Utada

Same here no skimmer




The new tank will have a algae turf scrubber, so I can feed more and not skim out the food.

29G cube/15G sump no filter sock zoa/paly tank only.

YES.
Odyssea PS 50
It works great and no noise at all!

No skimmer on either of my tanks. Instead, I do weekly water changes and have chaetomorpha in a "refugium" chamber in the back of each tank.

No skimmer here I been running 2+ years and ran a skimmer for one week in all that time. That was about 18 month ago and the damn thing drove me crazy with the constanst ajustmants the noise and the micro bubbles.

My reef gets along fine without it and I don't add or have to add other products to the tank either as the weekly water changes are enough to keep them right.

I seem to be averaging about a bucket of salt a year and have my own RO unit so the water changes aren't expensive to do anyway. Why should I put up with a skimmer?

currently am running skimmer less..have been running skimmer less for an year now, but am working in a new sump and will be installing a larger skimmer with the new sump.

No skimmer on my 10nano reef. HOB refug and water changes. More simpler is more gooder.

use an Aqua C nano on my 28. Live rock, light and protein skimmers are the 3 major components of any saltwater setup that I have.

Lifereef in sump skimmer. giggidy