varanus37
Oct 17 2009, 07:40 PM
So this tank has been somewhat a byline in my other 2 tank threads for some time. I got interested in picos after wandering around this forum and seeing some of the really neat things people create. The idea for this tank came from a few different places. I don't really keep acros in my other displays. The 10 gallon is my wife's tank and she digs rics and softies and my 75 is a jumble of all things coral but I really like montis. I do go to RC occasionally (gasp!) and run through the large tank section there. I'm always impressed by the mammoth creations that some people have and I really like to look at them but I just couldn't bring myself to build a tank like that and have nothing but acros in it. It's so pretty but so boring.
This brings me to my present project. I found this random betta cube at petsmart for like $10 and snagged it. It has a sweet fake snake skin base and looks as cheesy as possible. Maybe if it were actually a caricature of Nemo with a fish bowl inside it would be cheesier but it's really a toss up. Now, I drill this little cube and plumb it to a 2.5 and what do you know? It holds water and has a nice flow. So what do I want to do with it? I want to recreate those monster acro forests I see on RC so often! So I jumped on Evil's group buy and picked up 2 of his 12k LED Pico lamps and there the tank sat for quite some time. I just recently moved so it wasn't a big hurry. Wandering through Menards I found a track lighting system that I think will work nicely so I picked it up and put it all together tonight. That's what prompted me to create this thread.
Some pics.
Random shot of what I have now. The 2.5 and return pump are elsewhere but who needs them for gluing and testing lights?

How the lights should be situated over the tank. Possibly on a shelf or in a cabinet of some sort.

This brings me to the pics through the actual front pane of the tank. It looks like crap right now I'll just tell you. I'm using snail shells as my back wall and I'm only about 1/4 done so just go with it.
Shot from above.

This is with the lights off in the room and just the 2 LED bulbs firing.

So there you have it. The start to my pico thread. Why a snail shell background you ask? Because I've seen rock walls done and they're really neat. I wanted something different. I like encrusting montis and chalice-type corals and I plan to place 2 or 3 pieces and let them grow to cover the back wall. How neat will it be to see the growth patterns of encrusters over a jumble of snail shells? I think it will be pretty neat indeed. The plan for the acros is 4 or 5 pieces placed either directly on the bottom of the tank or using frag plugs with the bases set flush with the tank bottom. I'm hoping for an orchard type of look but we'll see. Not sure on the actual acro types or anything that I'll be using. Likely random cheap/freebies from my reef club. I've got 2 in my 75 now that may make the move along with a birdsnest piece. I've also got 2 acro crabs in the 75 and I would love to get another and basically make this whole thing a home for him.
So if you bothered to read all of that tell me what you think.
Bill
ashaf22789
Oct 17 2009, 07:58 PM
Looks kinda cool. The shell wall is an interesting idea. Would be cool to grow some corals right out of the shells. How big is the pump your going to be using?
varanus37
Oct 17 2009, 08:24 PM
That was partly my reason for leaving some of the shells facing upward. Depending on what I go with for the encrusters I may place a piece in one of those openings. If I use monti encrusters on one side then the thought was to put a digi in the shell opening. If I use a chalice as the encruster then the shell openings will stay empty so they don't sting each other.
The pump is an old Rio 1100 I had chilling in the parts box. It says 1450 LPM, no idea what that works out to in gallons. I turn it down quite a bit as the sump sits fairly close to the display so it doesn't take much power to get the water back up and I don't want to overflow it.
Bill
evilc66
Oct 17 2009, 09:32 PM
Make sure you vent those cans. The lamps will get really toasty in there without a way for heat to escape.
varanus37
Oct 17 2009, 09:37 PM
Yeah they're going to be drilled. Do you think a comp fan or something of that sort would be necessary? If I ended up doing this in a cabinet of some sort I could put a comp fan in the wall and have it run across the top/back of the bulbs with the vent holes drilled out.
On a side note, if you're looking for a tank to deck out with LED's then you should check out the Fluval Edge. Saw it in an LFS today. It's a new type of FW AIO tank but it looks pretty neat. The way the lights are set up it's just begging to be stuffed with LED's to make a reef.
Bill
evilc66
Oct 17 2009, 09:39 PM
Fans shouldn't be necessary depending on how many holes you drill.
The Edge is an interesting tank. There has been some discussion around here on how to improve the lighting, but unless you DIY something, all other options suck. Don't know if I'd want it for a reef though. You'd have to take a gallon of water out just to put your hand in it.
varanus37
Oct 17 2009, 09:42 PM
I agree that it is more pretty than effective. Today was the first time I'd seen one and with that little space for lighting it has LED's were the only thing I could think of to put there.
Bill
Nemo Niblets
Oct 17 2009, 09:47 PM
You could submerge a giant orb of LIGHT!!! And then wrap some cool fake plants on it. Then it will be a giant PLANT-VEINED orb of light. Then you could put disco colors in it and let them spin around and get like 20 sexy shrimp and let them DANCE!!!
varanus37
Oct 17 2009, 09:52 PM
Very true but with the flow rolling through this little bugger I don't think sexies would be happy. We'll see how it goes.
Bill
DHaut
Oct 17 2009, 09:54 PM
QUOTE (Nemo_Niblets @ Oct 17 2009, 10:47 PM)

You could submerge a giant orb of LIGHT!!! And then wrap some cool fake plants on it. Then it will be a giant PLANT-VEINED orb of light. Then you could put disco colors in it and let them spin around and get like 20 sexy shrimp and let them DANCE!!!
back away from the LSD
also, OP, what's the plan on keeping water quality stable?
Nemo Niblets
Oct 17 2009, 09:59 PM
darn
varanus37
Oct 17 2009, 10:21 PM
I'm not entirely sold yet. Obviously top-off is huge in a tank this small with an open top. Not sure if I want to make the sump a 5.5 and chaeto ball it up or not. Also considered Chemi-pure and Purigen. I have a spare skimmer but it's volume is actually more than my display, LOL. Since I want to go SPS in this tank water quality is a concern for me. Quality is always a concern but keeping xenia and shrooms in a pico doesn't require the same quality as montis and acros IMO. I'm leaning toward the Chemi and Purigen route. Possibly a small HOB stuck on the sump. I like chaeto balls on larger tanks for the randomness of life that accumulates in them but I don't see a major benefit in this particular tank.
Bill
Nemo Niblets
Oct 17 2009, 10:28 PM
Get an AC 110
varanus37
Oct 17 2009, 10:35 PM
Eh, I've got lots of HOB randomness laying around so I'll probably just mod up my own. This tank is a random side project for me but I would like it to be long-term. I'm much more for the build it sweet on your own with what you've got laying around. My other 2 tanks had relatively little DIY so I'd like to use more here. The small size in and of itself almost necessitates that anyway.
Bill
MGDMIRAGE
Oct 17 2009, 11:12 PM
Cool project, it kinda looks like a Hermit Crab torture chamber. Why don't any of these shells i've put on move!!! aaaaaaaa!!!
varanus37
Oct 17 2009, 11:24 PM
That would be hilarious. Would be neat to have one of those hermits that lives commensally with poci in there. I wonder if he'd still want the commensal coral or if he'd take up residence in a shell? I'm hoping an acro crab will use it as a hidey hole when he's not out in the coral branches.
Bill
varanus37
Oct 18 2009, 07:00 PM
Picked up a bundle of shells today from a friend at a local LFS so I should be able to finish out the wall as far as the shells go. Thinking about sprinkling sand into the glue seams but I'm worried that it will look too much like grout in between tiles. I think over time coraline, etc. will cover the seams in between the shells and make for a natural look. I can deal with the white until then. My end goal is to have coral coverage of the back wall anyway.
I'm still a good while from having coral in this tank but I think I'm going to start on the back wall first and go with a monti. I'm leaning toward a sunset piece right now. We'll see what I pick up when the time comes but I don't think I'll find a better background than the orange of a sunset.
Bill
varanus37
Oct 18 2009, 08:38 PM
A few pics of shell placing in progress tonight. Here's the randomness of the back.

I lucked out with these 2 shells fitting the curve of the pipe.

My highly technical way of holding the shells in place while things dry. The PVC glue can happens to be just wide enough to fit in between the tank wall and a shell covering the overflow pipe and an angled Pepsi can puts good pressure on a big ol' shell that was sagging.

I'll try to get some pics up tomorrow when things are dry and I can look through the front pane. Still have to place a few more shells to get the pipe covered and even things out a bit toward the bottom.
Bill
RyanR1212
Oct 18 2009, 08:43 PM
LOL thats awesome!! i like it a lot and hopes it works out all well
varanus37
Oct 18 2009, 08:45 PM
Thank you very much. It is a very technical process as you can plainly see, LoL. Really thought it's coming along fairly well and my daughter is having a blast picking out shells and then telling me where they should go.
Bill
Needreefunds
Oct 18 2009, 09:07 PM
Neat little project Bill.
Not to be Mr. Negative, but, any worries about detritus build up in the upside down shells?
Suppose you could always top them with epoxy if need be.
Following along as usual.
varanus37
Oct 18 2009, 09:16 PM
That is a pretty solid worry. To be honest I'm not really sure. There are only a few shells that are upside down like that and I would imagine at least one or two will have frags in them. The FW runs that I've done with the tank have some pretty turbulent flow so I think most things will be kept in suspension. I am still considering the CUC for something this tiny so we'll see where it goes. Teresa's 10 gal. has dozens of stomatellas so I think I could swipe some of those and I really do want to see an acro crab in here. Beyond that we'll just have to see what I can come up with.
Bill
pismo_reefer
Oct 19 2009, 02:48 AM
im totally watchin this one....
varanus37
Oct 19 2009, 10:52 AM
Glad to hear it. That 9.5 looks sick. One of your pics made me think of a different way to go on the back wall. Maybe a monti or two to encrust on one side and maybe a cyphastrea on the other? Could be kewl.
Bill
Weetabix7
Oct 19 2009, 10:55 AM
I'll be watching this one, I think it has some interesting potential.

(Good catch, R

)
DHaut
Oct 19 2009, 10:57 AM
So if I have this right, you've got a .6g display and a 5g sump? Cool idea.
pismo_reefer
Oct 19 2009, 11:15 AM
QUOTE (varanus37 @ Oct 19 2009, 08:52 AM)

Glad to hear it. That 9.5 looks sick. One of your pics made me think of a different way to go on the back wall. Maybe a monti or two to encrust on one side and maybe a cyphastrea on the other? Could be kewl.
Bill
thx.

and I'd go w/ the monti's, as cyphastrea's grow hella slow.... (like 3/4" a year)
varanus37
Oct 19 2009, 01:15 PM
Thanx Weet.
Yes, the sump/fuge tank will be just a bit under 10x the size of the display. Odd, I know.
Good call on the cyphastrea growing crazy slow. Really though with the tank being this small I could still roll one or two montis and then place a cyphastrea for good measure. If the montis grow to cover then I still get what I want and I'll also have a nook or corner with a nice cyphastrea in it. 3/4-1" a year wouldn't be too bad for this little tank. 3 years or so and I'd have a nice cyphastrea half-wall.
Bill
Urchinhead
Oct 19 2009, 02:24 PM
I have this exact tank sitting behind me right now. I was going to put a beta in there but now... I need to gin up a way to have the sump under the tank as a part of the stand... I see the drain but what about the return?
mew
Oct 19 2009, 05:18 PM
I always wanted to do a
zero edge with that tank.
rickjg
Oct 20 2009, 12:05 AM
QUOTE (mew @ Oct 19 2009, 03:18 PM)

I always wanted to do a
zero edge with that tank.
Unfortunately I took down my little
0.5G 0-edge FW pico < ...

... It had a couple of design issues that made it rather high maintenance. Also my wife kept freaking out & unplugging everything when the ATO air pump starting going ... I have to admit the ATO air pump was pretty loud! }

{
Bill, I like your idea of running a fuge 10X the size of the display. I'm really looking forward to more updates.
-Rick
varanus37
Oct 20 2009, 12:33 AM
I've added what I think are the last of the shells.
With the dining room lights.


With the LED's.

Milana showing my wife Teresa where she helped.

The front pane is still grubby and I need to clean things up but I wanted to get pics up of the wall so there you have it.
My return is fairly shabby looking but kinda neat IMO. You know the angled nozzle heads that fit on the end of pumps? I wanted to cut a slot in the side of the tank that would match that nozzle and have the water coming in from there. So really you'd never see anything in the tank but coral, no plumbing at all. I may still make the cuts, I just haven't decided if I'm brave enough to screw it up. Right now I've got the nozzle angled so that it lays across the top of the shells and points down into the tank. I haven't permanently placed it there but I set things up to check the fit and it sits how I intended. I'd really like to make the cuts though and have it so you can't see anything. An idea along those lines was to make my own stand that enclosed the tank more and hide the return line in there leading to the wall of the tank and the cut opening to the nozzle. That way you wouldn't see anything looking through the front pane or just passing by the tank.. That view through the front pane is really my concern here. I want to take pics through the front pane and be able to see what I see in my head now. If you look above the tank and around it and see equipment I don't really care, it would just be nice to pull it off all sleek. If not, oh well.
Hope some of that made sense.
Bill
varanus37
Oct 20 2009, 12:30 PM
So the epoxy held just fine and all of the shells are still in place and look good this morning. Planning to do a WC on the 75 after work tonight or first thing tomorrow morning and may get some water going in here as well. Need to get the panes cleaned up and scrape some epoxy here and there first.
Bill
varanus37
Oct 21 2009, 02:18 AM
Ugh, got off work way too late for a WC or anything but Nyquil and a hot shower. I think there's a brick growing inside my face.
1000+ views though so thanks for checking out the thread all.
Bill
spankyleatherlips
Oct 21 2009, 11:14 AM
Great job on the shells Milana
I have enjoyed this thread. Keep up the good work and best of luck.
fisheyman
Oct 21 2009, 11:32 AM
can you keep coral in a tank that small?
varanus37
Oct 21 2009, 12:38 PM
Absolutely. Coral have certain needs depending on their species and so long as you meet their needs they'll live here just like anywhere else. Water quality, temp, light source, etc. All I'm doing is making it harder for myself to maintain those stable levels really, haha. I'm doing this tank for the neat factor but also for the personal challenge.
Bill
varanus37
Nov 1 2009, 08:32 PM
So I think I know how I'm going to set the tank up. We have a bookshelf in our dining room that has been in disarray since we moved and I think the tank is going in there. My other idea was in one of my entertainment center cubbies but they're too short to accomodate the lights. The bookshelf has the moveable shelves so fitting things up shouldn't be too difficult. I mocked it up and things look alright. I'll get some pics up when I drill for the plumbing to come through the shelf.
Bill
KevinStan
Nov 3 2009, 06:57 PM
Looking good!
Glad to see I am not the only one using this betta tank as a reef tank.....
You can check out my thread I just started on mine... you are a bit further on yours so far though....
Best of luck... keep it up....
varanus37
Nov 4 2009, 01:06 AM
I think it's a great tank for it. It was cheap and it has nice dimensions for what I want to do. Best of luck with yours.
Bill
Jacobnano
Nov 4 2009, 01:13 AM
This has some amazing potential. Makes me want to plumb a tiny little tank to my 24g!
I really hope it works out to be an awesome little SPS forest, that would be really cool.
nosser
Nov 4 2009, 02:17 AM
cool project.... following along
varanus37
Nov 4 2009, 03:42 AM
Thank you both. Since you mentioned plumbing a tiny tank to your larger one it sparked a memory. Over on RC there was a guy with a monster reef and he had a little cube over the top of his fuge/sump. I would imagine bigger than mine but same idea. He used a small pump and ran water up to this thing and I think had just a little pvc return like I have. He kept his sun coral and stuff in there. That way it's all contained and separate and you can feed it all you want. I thought it was a pretty neat idea. If you did shelves beneath your tank you could put windows in your stand and show off smaller specific critters. Sun coral is one idea and I thought about a mantis shrimp being another. That way you can have your sweet reef and some things that don't always go well in that sweet reef.
Bill
varanus37
Nov 4 2009, 01:28 PM
Hey, 2000 views! Thanks for tagging along everyone. My little blurb in my last post about keeping little tanks below your display may have given me an interesting idea.
Bill
varanus37
Dec 5 2009, 02:56 PM
If you're anywhere near the south side of Chicago you are invited to the-store-formerly-known-as Go Fish in Orland Park. The Joliet Area Reef Club is having a membership drive! We'd love to see you all out there. I'll be there around 6 PM tonight along with a good chunk of the rest of the club. If you want to come out earlier in the day and check out the store feel free. It's a great place...birds, reptiles and reef all in one shot. Hope you can all come!
Bill
Damsels R Cool
Dec 17 2009, 10:11 PM
any updates
Thunderstruck34
Dec 17 2009, 10:15 PM
Really cool idea with the snail shell backing! can't wait to see how this thing turns out.
varanus37
Dec 18 2009, 01:25 AM
Thank you.
Sorry about the lack of updates. Our 3rd baby, and 1st boy, is due any day now so reefing is sort of on autopilot right now. Just maintenance on the main tanks and this project is chilling out. I should have 2 solid weeks off for the holidays and baby leave so the plan is to work on this tank more during that time.
Thanks for tagging along.
Bill
evilc66
Dec 18 2009, 11:04 AM
Congrats. Hope everything goes smoothly.
KevinStan
Dec 18 2009, 11:06 AM
Congrats... I am looking forward to some updates on it... I will be updating mine soon also....
Good luck with the newborn and the tank both
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please
click here.